Mon 10 Apr 2006
N today’s mobile society, it’s becoming far easier –and perhaps even more desirous– to bring Holmes with you in forms other than those derived from dead trees (as much a fan of dead trees as I am). We’ve already seen here how Old Time Radio shows can be snapped onto your iPod in a matter of minutes, but what about carrying the actual texts digitally?
While there are a number of online services that allow one to use a Palm or other PDA (personal data assistant) to download and read ebooks –that is, “electronic books” for those unfamiliar with the term– these are often rather expensive, with pricing approximately the same as published paper books. In the limited selection of classics available, this seems quite costly indeed, especially given that copyright has elapsed for most of them (there’s therefore no royalties to be paid), and there’s no physical materials or costs to pass long to the consumer.
Well, don’t fret, because many of the works of Sir Arthur Conan Doyle can be downloaded for free at Blackmask Online : Mystery/Arthur Conan Doyle. They have a variety of formats, including ones that can be opened in Adobe Acrobat, or a regular web browser (the “zipped” archives). But I love this site because of the various mobile formats, and in particular the files readable under Plucker or iSilo on my Palm. All I have to do is download, drag them to my install bucket, hit the button, and a few minutes later, I have dozens of works ready to go.
If this isn’t enough to satisfy your classic mystery fancies, you can also find Emile Gaboriau and his Lecoq, Sir Arthur’s brother-in-law E. W. Hornung and his gentleman cracksman Raffles, and Maurice Leblanc, who brought us Arsene Lupin.
If BlackMask doesn’t have what you’re looking for, try MemoWare, and do a search for “Conan Doyle”. There’s plenty of selections and formats there too, but I generally find a little more love and care in general goes into the BlackMask ebooks.
An added benefit of these ebooks, of course, is that you can take along books that are almost impossible to find in bookstores, even the online ones, with the possible exception of print-on-demand services and their variable quality. (Fans of ACD who have tried to track down the rare A Visit to Three Fronts or The Mystery of Cloomber can no doubt appreciate what I’m saying.)
One last word, regarding copyrights. In you live in the U.S., copyrights are still in force for those books published from 1923 onwards, so the act of downloading certain books (The Case-Book of Sherlock Holmes is an example) is a violation under the Sonny Bono Act. If you live in the U.K., Canada (where I live), or most other countries which have signed the Berne Convention, the Conan Doyle copyrights expired as of 1980, and so downloading does not seem to be an issue. (At least, this is my understanding, but I am certainly not a lawyer: please let me know if you have legal evidence to the contrary.) For more information, see The Canon, the Copyrights, the Confusion.
6 Responses to “You CAN take it with you…”
Leave a Reply
You must be logged in to post a comment.

April 10th, 2006 at 5:37 pm
Now if you could just tell me what the copyright situation with the illustrations by Frank Wiles (who did Valley of Fear and three short stories in Case-book) is, I’d be happy…
(Not that I don’t love your Sherlockian blog as it is!)
April 10th, 2006 at 6:54 pm
A good question, Paula! Wiles’ illustration (in my header at top right) has definitely become an icon of Sherlockiana, and besides Conan Doyle’s admission that it was the closest to Holmes’ image in his own mind, has graced untold thousands of books and other commercial products: t-shirts, caps, posters, pub signs, dart boards, hotels, and more. Looking through some of these items in my own possession (alas, no hotel, though), I see a rare attribution to Wiles in some of them, but nothing about rights.
If anybody wishes to assert any (legally valid) rights in the matter, I’d be more than happy to remove the image. However, I have a feeling the the legal team in question will be very busy for years tracking down those degenerates actually making money.
And, dear me, I might have to do something halfway original! Anyone have a deerstalker and ulster to loan me that I can dress a stuffed penguin in?
dj
April 11th, 2006 at 1:44 am
Oh, I didn’t really mean is as a stab at your header image
It’s just that I’ve been trying to find out about this for quite a while, since I’d like to use some Wiles illustrations myself, and no-one has been able to help me at all. Seems like nobody knows anything about the man except his name…
April 11th, 2006 at 10:29 am
Paula, don’t worry: I was just musing aloud. I’ve been so wrapped up these past few years in copyright/ patent/ trademark issues whenever I produce any content that I’m always trying to watch my step. (Did you know that Microsoft has a patent on double-clicking? Ridiculous.)
As for Wiles, your guess is as good as mine. When I get a bit of time, I think I’ll do a bit of research myself. Given that Wiles’ most famous illustration appeared in 1914 (was it? trying to remember…), I should think that this one in particular is no longer covered by copyright. That seems to be backed up with its appearance on almost every product without due attribution. Of course, I’m not a lawyer, and my legal knowledge approximates that of a small furry animal, so anyone listening to me for advice would clearly be insane.
dj
April 15th, 2006 at 10:31 pm
No worries. The statement at the bottom of this page covers your obligation, dj.
November 12th, 2008 at 7:34 pm
ru1zayur6qbhl9os